Please login or create an account to join the discussion.

Modelling the impacts of a healthy diet on CVD and cancer

This paper is by some of the same authors who wrote a paper for Friend of the Earth (see mailing of 23/10/10) which modelled the health impact of a lower meat diet. You can read the FoE report here.

The FOE report essentially argues that a lower meat diet would deliver major health improvements largely because it assumes that a reduction in meat intakes will be compensated for by an increase in fruit and vegetables – which of course may or may not be the case.

This paper is by some of the same authors who wrote a paper for Friend of the Earth a few months ago (see mailing of 23/10/10) which modelled the health impact of a lower meat diet. You can read the FoE report here.

The FOE report essentially argues that a lower meat diet would deliver major health improvements largely because it assumes that a reduction in meat intakes will be compensated for by an increase in fruit and vegetables – which of course may or may not be the case.

Anyway, this paper looks at what would happen if the population consumed in line with UK govt health recommendations as regards fat intakes, salt, fibre and so forth.  It calculates that around 33,000 deaths would be avoided a year. Reference and abstract as follows.

Scarborough P, Nnoaham K E, Clarke D, Capewell S and Rayner M (2011). Modelling the impact of a healthy diet on cardiovascular disease and cancer mortality. J. Epidemiol Community Health doi:10.1136/jech.2010.114520

Abstract

Background Quantifying the potential health benefits of improvements in the nutritional quality of the average diet of a population would provide evidence for resource allocation between population-level interventions aimed at reducing chronic disease. Methods A model was built linking consumption of food components with biological risk factors (blood pressure, serum cholesterol and obesity) and subsequent mortality from coronary heart disease, stroke and cancer. Meta-analyses of individual-level studies that quantified the RR of increased consumption/increased risk factor level on disease outcomes were used to build the model. The sensitivity of the model to the results from the meta-analyses was assessed with Monte Carlo simulations. Country-specific estimates of current nutrient intake compared against dietary recommendations for the UK were used to demonstrate the model. Results Approximately 33 000 deaths per year would be avoided if UK dietary recommendations were met. The modelled reduction in deaths for coronary heart disease was 20 800 (95% credible interval 17 845–24 069), for stroke 5876 (3856–7364) and for cancer 6481 (4487–8353). Over 15 000 of the avoided deaths would be due to increased consumption of fruit and vegetables. Conclusions The developed model estimates the impact of population-level dietary changes and is robust. Achieving UK dietary recommendations for fruit and vegetable consumption (five portions a day) would result in substantial health benefits—equivalent benefits would be achieved if salt intakes were lowered to 3.5 g per day or saturated fat intakes were lowered to 3% of total energy.

You can download the paper here. (This is a pay service.)

Post a new comment »

Login or register to comment with your personal account. Anonymous comments require approval to be visible.
Publication
03 Mar 2011
Actors
Region