Episode summary
Why are we drawn to simple fixes for the complex challenge of feeding the world sustainably? Researchers Colin Sage (formerly Cork University) and Garrett Broad (Rowan University) unpack what we're calling "food solutionism"—the tendency to promote single, sweeping solutions, whether high-tech or agroecological, while ignoring context and complexity. They argue for "complicating the narrative early and often", so we can move beyond binary thinking and better understand the trade-offs, limits, and realities behind competing visions for the future of food.
The Blue Sky Thread that prompted this conversation
About the guests
Garrett Broad
Dr. Garrett Broad is an Associate Professor of Communication Studies and Provost’s Fellow for Sustainability at Rowan University. His research and teaching focus on the role of media and communication in movements for healthy and sustainable food systems. He is the author of the book More Than Just Food: Food Justice and Community Change and serves as president of the board for the non-profit Plant-Based Foods Institute.
Colin Sage
Colin Sage is an independent research scholar now based in Portugal. He is an Affiliated Professor with the Faculty of Nutrition and Food Sciences at the University of Porto, and Visiting Professor at the University of Gastronomic Sciences, Italy. He was previously Senior Lecturer in Geography at University College Cork, Ireland. He is the author of Environment and Food (Routledge, 2012); editor of A Research Agenda for Food Systems (Elgar, 2022), and co-editor of five other books. He was a co-founder of the Cork Food Policy Council and served as its chair from 2013-2019.
About the host
Jack Thompson
Jack Thompson is a food and climate journalist, based in West Africa. He writes for global media outlets such as the Financial Times, The Associated Press and The Sunday Times, and is the editor of TABLE's newsletter Fodder. You can read some of his work here.
References and recommended resources
Essay: The Flawed Ideology That Unites Grass-Fed Beef Fans and Anti-Vaxxers
Article: Challenging high-tech solutionism in an era of polycrisis: A commentary on claims for novel foods and on building an alternative narrative. (Colin Sage, 2024)
Article: The City of Cork Food Policy Council – Inter-agency collaboration towards a fairer, healthier, more secure and sustainable local food system (Janas Harrington, 2023)
Book: Elite Capture How the Powerful Took Over Identity Politics (And Everything Else) (Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò, 2022)
Article: Can agroecology and CRISPR mix? The politics of complementarity and moving toward technology sovereignty (Maywa Montenegro de Wit, 2022)
Book: High Conflict: Why We Get Trapped and How We Get Out (Amanda Ripley, 2021)
Article: From protecting peasant livelihoods to essentializing peasant agriculture: problematic trends in food sovereignty discourse (Rachel Soper, 2020)
Book: To Save Everything - Click Here (Evgeny Morozo 2013)
Related Feed episodes
Julie Guthman on Capital, Tech and Alternative Food
Jessica Duncan on COP28 and who shapes food policy
Is this the future of food? (with Michael Grunwald)
Tik Tok Masculinity and the TradWife
Comments (0)