Skip to main content

Matthew Kessler

Okay, let me set up what we’re trying to do here.

We at TABLE, the organization behind the now over 100 podcast episodes, have a snappy headline to describe our work in food systems: Visions. Values. Evidence.

Our starting point is that these three are all connected. Our values, our ideas of “what is good” - that informs both our vision of some desired future, and it plays a role on the evidence that we seek out and trust.

Since TABLE’s staff is all based in universities, obviously evidence is central. But it has become so apparent lately, that evidence can be political and politicized. So when we say "evidence," it's worth asking: whose evidence, filtered through what values?

To give you an example, what’s more important to you - preventing a child from going hungry, or a species from going extinct? Are your first thoughts with the eaters in cities or producers in the countryside? Are you optimistic or skeptical about technology?

These questions are in the background of what we’re going to explore in the next three episodes. We’ll hear two pretty far apart visions of a “good food system”. One is from a farmer with a PhD in agroecological transitions. The other is from a political scientist who wrote a book on food systems. While you’ll find some things in common, you’re going to hear a lot of disagreement, on topics like “the meat issue”, what food justice looks like, and what levers actually change food systems.

Fundamentally, one says the food system is working well, and here is how we can make it even  better, for the average food and farm worker and eater. That’s the reform camp. The other says the food system is broken, and we need a just transition to get to a radically new place. That’s transform. So, what do you think?

Welcome to Feed, a food systems podcast, presented by TABLE. I’m Matthew Kessler.

This is episode 1: How to Make the Food System Even Better
Who are you and what do you do for a living?

Jan Dutkiewicz

My name is Jan Dutkiewicz. I'm an assistant professor at the Pratt Institute and I'm a contributing editor at the New Republic.

Matthew

And you also are a co-author with Gabe Rosenberg of the book Feed the People, Why Industrial Food is Good and How to Make it Even Better. Provocative title.

Jan 

Yeah, well, you know, in the world of trade publishing, the subtitle is a little bit of a sales pitch. So it's not entirely ours, but I think it does capture the thrust of what the book tries to do, which is think through how to make the food system more sustainable and more just, at scale, while keeping the things that work in the incumbent food system. And really pushing back against ideas that we need a radical food system overhaul or that the food system is quote unquote broken. But yeah, maybe a tad bit more provocative than I would have chosen for, let's say, an academic text.

Matthew 

That's a good place to start. There's multiple stories that we tell ourselves about the food system. And these are stories and they're not always borne out by scientific evidence. So we're gonna unpack kind of where the discourse meets the real world here. Can you first tell me the story that the food writer, not just food writer, but the writer Michael Pollan tells about the food system?

Jan 

Michael Pollan is probably one of the most important voices in American food writing. I think he's the inheritor of the sort of mantle left by Wendell Berry, although Pollan is obviously an urbanite and not himself a farmer. And Pollan looks out at the American food system and he sees a lot of junk food. He sees the mass scale production of staple commodities grown at scale as monocrops.

He sees ill health outcomes among the American eating public, especially obesity, and he sees a sort of disconnection from the land. This is very much the Wendell Berry story, right, of the Unsettling of America in various terms. He asks this basic question in the Omnivore's Dilemma, which is, in a society of food abundance, of food plenty, where we can eat pretty much anything we want. What should we eat? 

And in his book, he investigates what we should eat. And he basically comes to the answer that we should look to small farms, small scale production, likely seasonal production, and something pretty close to what we'd now call broadly regenerative ranching.

So the de facto avatar for him in his book is Joel Salatin, is a small Virginia farmer, owner of a place called Polyface Farms, that does small-scale livestock as well as small-scale production mostly for a local economy. I mean, look, of course, Pollan and overlooks the fact that Salatin is a raging right winger, a libertarian and anti-vaxxer himself, has a book that's called Everything I'd like to do is illegal, which is basically a polemic against the regulatory state. But of course, none of this is included in Pollan’s story because Pollan is writing a book for liberal urbanites who are concerned with the source of dietary choices. They're making is he doesn't want to spoil their lunch by talking too much about politics since he gives the story of aesthetics masked in just-so stories about the alleged environmental and moral superiority of small-scale food production. 

Where Pollan is right in his broader writing is that Americans do eat quite poorly. So he's not wrong on the numbers. Americans do have overweight and obesity issues that are primarily dietary. 

Americans do die from dietary related diseases such as cardiovascular diseases. So he's not wrong that Americans should eat differently. But what he does is rather than doing a deeper food systems analysis, he engages in the sort of “just so” storytelling.

Which just says, well look, we just need to move to a world of small farms. He doesn't ask questions about the pragmatics of that move. He doesn't ask real questions about the potential environmental or public health outcomes of that move. So in a sense, what he has is he's got a pretty correct, if surface level, diagnosis of the problems, but a really poor and unfeasible prescription for how to address them.

Matthew

Hmm. you already mentioned some of the things that you agree with and disagree with Pollan. I'm going to ask you to do the same thing now, telling the story of the food system from Robert Paarlberg. So he’s a professor emeritus of political science at Harvard Kennedy School. And he's also written prolifically about the food system.

He's obviously writing both about the global food system and the US food system, but just for maybe the sake of comparison, we could focus more on the US.

Jan 

So in full disclosure, Robert Paarlberg did blurb our book, but I will do my best to give an objective analysis here. So Robert Paarlberg is the author of a book called Resetting the Table that I think everyone should read. I think even if you do not agree with Paarlberg's ideas, I think Resetting the Table is probably the strongest steel man of an argument in favor of conventional agriculture in the United States and its benefits.

So Robert Paarlberg looks out at the American food system and he basically sees a wonder of modern technology. He sees a world where for the first time in human history, we produce enough food for everyone, certainly in the United States, where the idea of food availability being the primary driver of food insecurity at a national level has been made obsolete and it's been made obsolete through the slate of technologies that we now refer to broadly as the Green Revolution technologies. Right, so gene editing, the use of petrochemical fertilizers and chemical pesticides, complex irrigation systems, and large scale growing of crops in large part with government support through things like land grant universities and the policies of the USDA.

So, Paarlberg starts from this point of view that we now eat better than we ever have. And if we just do some small technical tweaks, such as, for instance, more precise and therefore lower application of pesticides and fertilizers, that we've basically got the recipe on the table for feeding Americans better and doing so efficiently. 

And of course, he's therefore also a believer that the benefits of efficiency can transfer into things that I'm sure your listeners already know about and perhaps have thoughts about, such as land sparing, right? Which is producing more on less land so that agriculture doesn't actually sprawl and have the broad land use change and biodiversity impacts that it would otherwise. 

And Paarlberg is also very critical of the well-meaning, sort of liberal and left well-meaning critics of the modern food system, the type of people who would read Pollan. So for instance, he really has no time for groups like Via Campesina. He has no time for opponents of genetic modification arguing that there is absolutely no proof that the genetic modification of organisms is noxious to human health. And so in fact, he believes that genetic modification and gene editing should be embraced specifically because it can increase efficiency and perhaps decrease the use of those chemical inputs on a per unit basis. So that's basically his argument that the food system works and it works in large part because of technological advances.

Matthew 

And how would you differentiate yourself from Paarlberg?

Jan 

In our book, we start from - when it comes to actual food production, we start from much the same place as Paarlberg. Gabriel and I tend to agree that producing more food more efficiently is on balance a good thing and a necessary thing, especially on a planet of 8 billion people, where very few people actually still work in agriculture, especially if we're talking about the global north, especially if we're talking about the United States.

But what we do in the book is we bring more of a broad-based food systems analysis to the issue because what we really want to think about is not just food production and food availability, but we want to think about food distribution, which is to say, how do we address food insecurity? Because just producing more food by itself doesn't actually mean more people get to eat food. There are many other barriers to food access. We want to think more deeply about what it is we produce, not just how we produce it.

So we want to think through the broader sustainability and environmental impacts of food production and think about what we should keep producing at scale and efficiently and what we shouldn't. We also think a lot about labor and the question of labor in the food system. 

And finally, we spent some time thinking about nutrition or in academic terms about utilization, which is once people actually have food access, how do they convert that and do they convert that into more nutritious food? 

So in a sense, we take, if you want to put this in the context of your previous two questions. We take Pollan’'s critique of the food system on board, even if we don't agree with all of it, and we try to deconstruct where the food system works and where it doesn't.

And while we start with agreeing with Paarlberg, we then delve much more deeply into the politics of sustainability, food security, food utilization and labor in a way that he doesn't in Resetting the table.

Matthew 

I was going to address this later, but I think it might be helpful to get your vision of the food system. So you've got this mantra, “more food, less feed, no biofuel.” Maybe we could spell out what that means.

Jan 

Sure. So I would say that our vision of a better food system starts not with that mantra, but with a slightly different one, which is that we think that the average meal for the average person should be more accessible and healthier and also delicious. Right? So the question then becomes, how do we improve the average meal?

And working backwards, we think that that can be accomplished through growing the right crops at scale, having the right policies in place to redistribute that food to people who may be food insecure, and picking the most sustainable crops to do that, and doing that within a context of a labor system that treats labor more justly.

The first thing you said is our vision for a production system that keeps what works, which is efficiency and does away with what doesn't work, which is inefficient use of land and crops, which is turning them into animal feed, primarily for animals in factory farms, and burning them for biofuels. In the United States, well over half of crops, the statistic we use in the book, although that's now a few years old, is over 65% of crops are not grown directly for human consumption. They're turned into biofuel, supported by federal biofuel mandates. This means that a tremendous amount of land is used to grow crops like corn and soy that become fuel additives and are burned, and that recent research suggests that if you do a sort of cradle to grave emissions analysis, it actually doesn't reduce the emissions of gas. So this is basically just a handout to farmers to use extremely efficient technology to grow crops for an extremely inefficient end. In fact, for an end that may hurt the climate in the guise of helping the climate. So it's a nonsensical policy. I think biofuels should not exist.

And second of all, animal feed. 99% of chickens, 97% of pork in the United States comes from factory farms. Over 65% of cattle is finished on industrial feedlot. Well, all the horrors of those production systems aside to animals, to labor, if you just think of the raw input necessary, if those animals are not, when they're on feedlots or factory farms are not grazing, they need to be fed food. That food has to be grown somewhere. 

So a tremendous amount of American and in fact global farmland is used to grow feed that's fed to those animals. Again, using the incredible efficiency of the way we know how to grow crops for an extremely inefficient end. Any given animal will consume far more calories and protein and feed than it will yield as meat once it's slaughtered, right? So this is called the calorie or protein feed conversion ratio.

Even for chickens which are arguably the most quote-unquote efficient meat to grow, that conversion ratio still sits at about 13% So getting our calories and protein from meat, especially doing it from systems that rely on the use of land to grow monocrop corn and soy again for animal feed is just a massively inefficient use. It's a waste of the efficiencies of crop production on an inhumane environmentally noxious and fundamentally inefficient system of food production. 

On the other hand, we agree entirely with Robert Paarlberg that the way we grow crops for human food is now more efficient than ever. We have very high yields. We're very good at growing crops using technology such as, for instance, computer-supported, I hesitate to say AI-supported, because I'm not entirely sold on that, but technologically supported spot application of things like pesticides. 

We can reduce the use of pesticides and other petrochemical and chemical inputs. In fact, we now use less per hectare than we did at the height of, you know, like when Rachel Carson wrote Silent Spring, we now use far fewer pesticides. It doesn't mean we don't use a lot of pesticides because we have a lot of acreage dedicated to crops. But we think that there are tweaks that can be applied. But overall, we were really good at producing crops for human food. And we think that we should keep doing that. We do it in a way that's labor efficient, that's land efficient, and that produces an abundance of food.

The United States is, I mean, nevermind imports for gustatory reasons and other reasons, but the United States is food secure. We could feed all Americans off a plant-based diet, off American crop land, in fact, far less crop land than we currently do. And we think that that's ultimately a good thing.

Matthew

So you've mentioned the word efficiency a bunch of times, and I see that's really important. And I think people are also listening and understanding that when you say efficiency, it's translating to if you were in an inefficient system, you would be using a lot more land to grow the same amount, or you would be applying a lot more fertilizers, a lot more pesticides. 

Jan 

An inefficient system produces less with more inputs, right? And you also could have mentioned labor, right? Because if you look at any statistics that compare conventional systems to non-conventional systems, some of which suggest that unconventional or pre-conventional systems. That's really hard to define, right? Because a farm could be small and still use petrochemical and modern inputs and so on. But what you find is that the root of any potential advantages in yields come from labor. 

And so if we want more farm labor, then that's a conversation we can have. But we know that all signs point to people not wanting to labor on farms. There's a reason that in the United States over half of agricultural workers are migrants. And the same goes for a lot of countries in the global north. The same certainly is true of Canada. And this is not an argument against migrant labor. This is an argument that proves that if there was sufficient interest among the domestic workforce in agricultural labor, this wouldn't be an issue. 

So I think that ultimately freeing people from the drudgery of farm work is a good thing. And being able to feed people with less people working on the land is also a good thing. And before people come in here talking about the nobility of farm work and what have you, if you're talking about large scale production systems, work on farms is either driving or otherwise using large scale mechanical implements or doing extremely difficult work. 

For instance, during harvest time, picking berries, picking asparagus, and so on and so forth. The more we can automate that and the more we can keep production levels high using less labor, I think is ultimately a good thing.

Matthew

A place we can transition here, I think, naturally, is to talk about food processing. So food processing, the history of it, is just bound up in saving labor in the kitchen. And when you hear people talk about - people don't usually say food processing, they say processed foods or ultra processed foods. That's kind of the way that people generally get into these food systems conversations. 

In your book, you talk about food processing kind of as a miracle. Can you expand on that a little bit more about what are some of the examples that you find so amazing about food processing, and then talk about in the wider food systems context.

Jan 

I mean look, one of food's biggest problems is perishability. You grow food, you harvest it, or you kill an animal. Now the clock's running. 

Being able to make food in some way shelf stable through processes such as canning or adding preservatives for instance or adding other things such as salts for instance to help preserve foods. And doing this in a way that's safe massively decreases food waste and increases food availability and access, especially for urban populations or people who don't live close to food. That's number one. 

Number two, historically, if you take a real historical view of nutrition, you go back to this sort of halcyon time of small scale Jeffersonian farmers, you know, during the westward expansion of the United States or even after the settling of America to go back to Wendell Berry's formulation. This is a deeply unhealthy country.

Diseases of malnutrition are rampant. Pellagra is killing hundreds of thousands of people in the American South. Goiters, marasmus, anemia are all common. In New York City in the year 1900, something north of 60%, maybe 70%, it's in the book, of school-aged children have some degree of rickets, which is caused by vitamin D deficiency. When the United States does the draft to enter World War I in some constituencies, well over 30% of men are turned away because of ailments or physical insufficiencies, in large part caused by malnutrition. We were not a hearty and healthy people. And much of that had to do with what we ate.

This is fixed in part by what I just talked about. Which is, basic food science, making food shelf stable, able to, foods being canned, foods being dried. It's also added by fortification. So early food science, basically in the wake of the work by Kazimierz Funk on vitamins, sort of the discovery of vitamins. Food fortification, for instance, adding vitamin D to milk, adding iodine to salt, adding iron back into milled mass produced bread does away with all, virtually all of these diseases of malnutrition almost overnight. Pasteurization reduces child mortality by close to 25%. So food processing brings us into a modern age where we can go to the supermarket or to the restaurant and not only expect that food will be there, but that food will be affordable and that it will be safe.

So that's where we start. And then from there, we basically argue that, when it comes to food processing and ultra processing, what really matters is what the process is that is used to process food. And if we're talking about adding any kind of ingredients to the food, whether those ingredients are healthy or not. So what matters is the nutritional content of individual foods.

I mean, the running example we use is something like an Impossible Burger, which exists to give people a tasty alternative to beef. Beef is arguably the worst food in the entire food system. Its livestock contribute the most to emissions, primarily through methane, of the entire food system. Red meat has been shown to be potentially carcinogenic by the WHO. Certainly carcinogenic if it's processed, especially with the addition of nitrites and salts. And so creating an alternative to beef seems like a very good idea, and doing it out of plants is, going back to my previous point, far more efficient. So just the fact that you're using a mixture of soy, methylcellulose, a little bit of added sodium, potentially some stabilizers. That is actually, you know, it's a use case for the beauty of food processing, what it can create. That you can create a food that's far more environmentally sound, slightly higher sodium levels aside, that's completely healthy, and that can be, that's shelf stable and that can be widely distributed.

That's basically our argument for food processing. We can create a far wider range of far better foods if we want to. Whether or not we do and to what ends processing is put is a different question. That's a question of corporate interests and political economy. 

Matthew

As we’ve been talking about, Jan Dutkiewicz doesn’t want to fundamentally transform a quote unquote broken food system. He wants to continue to see a highly efficient food system, supported by appropriate technology and research, working towards more healthful and sustainable aims. You may recall the mantra: more food, less feed, no biofuel. I want to now dive into the mechanics of turning this vision into a reality.

Jan and Gabriel spend a good section of their book talking about food culture, and speaking specifically about the pleasures of eating. A lot of people’s conception of a pleasurable meal comes from Wendell Berry and Michael Pollan, and it has a very specific aesthetic to it. Farm-to-table, know your farmer, food systems rooted in communities. Jan and Gabriel write about pleasure too, though they have a very different philosophy.

Jan 

Michael Pollan and Wendell Berry, especially Wendell Berry, who wrote this famous essay, The Pleasures of Eating, their idea of food pleasure has less to do with the empirical, tangible pleasure eaters actually take from eating, so it's not an empirical question. It's more a question about adhering to their vision of a better food system. So for Wendell Berry, for instance, the real pleasure in eating comes from knowing where your food comes from, producing as much of it as you can yourself, being in relation with the people who produce your food and so on and so forth. Right, and the idea being that there's this sort of extensive pleasure to that rather than the, you know, the pleasure of the mere gourmand that comes from eating. But I just don't think that's how most people experience food. I think people just like things they like and don't like things that they don't like. I mean, and of course, the flip side of that is that you can't just embrace people being gourmands, you can't just, you know, embrace pure food hedonism, because that also can lead us in some dangerous directions, right? Such as just saying, well, you know, eat whatever you want, regardless of the impact. 

So we think of this much more in terms of this concept that we call democratic hedonism, which is asking how we can maximize access to food pleasures for people while being honest about the potential harms and downsides of those pleasures. And so what that means in practice is just to use a few examples.

If you want to reduce meat consumption, then... I mean, number one, I don't think the Michael Pollans of the world want to reduce meat consumption. I mean, you know, it's just sort of like hand wave away factory farms without realizing that if you do away with factory farms, everyone's basically vegan overnight. Not everyone can afford a polyface farm steak or pork chop or whatever. 

And so this is why, for instance, we think that if we're going to try to wean people off meat, whatever else we do, and we talk about a number of policies, such as, for instance, emissions taxes, so Pigouvian taxes on meat production, the closing of regulatory loopholes that allow meat to be produced so cheaply. We think that we should also think about things like having really good meat alternatives in order to facilitate the transition for people. 

So we think about a food system that can provide abundant pleasure, so not just saying, you know, have your one regenerative steak if you can afford it once a week, but let's try to meet you where you are. If you like burgers, can we make a slightly more sustainable burger that's served at a place where the workers have union protections? So a burger joint serving Impossible burgers where the workers are treated fairly looks to us like a much better part of the food system than some libertarian small-scale farm in rural Virginia. 

And so that's basically how we think about this concept of pleasure. We don't think that people shouldn't do their homework. I mean, we wrote a book about the food system. We think people should learn about the food system. But whether or not knowing more about the food system gives them more pleasure is an open question. I think the two can't be conflated in the way that Pollan and Berry do.

So we think that people should make educated choices, but we also think that we should design systems in order to maximize the pleasure and sort of keep latitude of choice for individuals, right? Like at some point, you know, I'm, I would say that I'm a liberal, right? And sort of left leaning, but classical liberal. I think that you have to allow people a latitude of choice. I think you can intervene in the public space in terms of education. You can use the regulatory state to disincentivize or incentivize certain forms of production, which is why we spend so much time there in the book. But I think when it comes to actual consumers, I mean, there's only so much that you can do to change how they eat. 

You can tweak the prices they face in the market. You can change the options they have in the market. You can use nudges to shunt them or nudge them, if you will, towards different foods. You can intervene in spaces where you have vulnerable populations or populations that don't have a lot of choice, such as schools. So for instance, we're big proponents of not just universal, but healthy school lunches. Of course, no sodas in school lunches, trying to make school lunches as healthy as possible to build good food habits. But when you're talking about a consumer in a supermarket, there's only so much you can do to really affect how they eat. I think we have to be quite honest about that. Some people just want to have some Doritos, and some people want a regenerative steak.

Barring very heavy-handed intervention into consumer markets. That's just how it's going to be. So what you can instead do is you can use policy to disincentivize the production of the most harmful things, and you can use policy to change pricing, and you can use policy to some extent to nudge consumers towards better choices. But you're sort of quite constrained. As long as you have a free market and you believe in the idea of consumer choice, you're quite constrained in what else you can do.

Matthew 

Yeah, I find all this super interesting because you are thinking about ideas of pleasure, which is what really informs a lot of people's eating decisions, similarly with affordability and convenience. But it also runs up against, I guess, critics from every direction. You know what I mean? So there's criticisms from the people who say we should see quote real food, the MAHA movement. There's criticisms from the sustainable food movement who are thinking about how we reduce all these harms embedded in the way that we produce our food and our diets. 

I wonder, as a next point of this is, who do you find to be the kind of natural political constituency for this argument? Like, who are the people that are gonna be, you from your view, championing this vision and taking it forward?

Jan 

If I were to think about who the constituency is for this kind of political movement, it would be the average food worker and the average eater. So not someone who's, you know, not someone who's actually all that concerned about food, qua food, but someone who's concerned about whether or not they can feed their kids a healthy diet, if their kids are eating healthy at school or if they have time to whip together a healthy lunch on a busy day.

Or workers who know firsthand that what really matters is how they're treated at work. I think a constituency of people who care broadly about public health and the environment and having continued access to cheap food that they ideally would like to be healthier and workers who want better wages. I think that that's the constituency.

Matthew 

Which is like, in a way it sounds obvious, but it's not something that's largely represented in academic discussions or like high minded discussions about what these systems should look like.

Ja 

Precisely. I think that's part of the problem with what these discussions are like. And look, going back to your previous point. Look, I'm vegan. I've been vegan for a very long time. I think animal agriculture is the biggest moral failure of modern society. I subscribe to normative arguments in favor of veganism. And I also recognize that the normative argument itself is very difficult to make and is difficult to make stick. And so I think if you're for instance committed to - and I should note that Gabriel my co-author is not vegan and we're quite clear about that in the book when we write about food pleasure and our approaches, our  sort of normative biases, if you will.

So, but the point is that this is why, you know, the question can't just, you can't just end at the normative argument. You have to think about how to make that normative argument stick, right? So you can tell people to eat quote unquote real food, but what's real food? Like is real food, is real food rotting eggs? Foodborne illnesses are completely natural. They're in fact the most natural part of real foods. I think a little bit of processing can help you have some of those foods without the risk of foodborne illnesses. You know, if I want someone to give veganism a try, I'd rather do it through an impossible burger than telling them to, you know, eat a Portobello burger or something else like that. And I think I just think that ultimately food systems change. I think a lot of people think about food systems change without thinking of the downstream effects on consumers. All food system change ultimately comes down to individuals changing their diets. And I think that that's quite simply, it's quite simply not talked about enough.

Matthew

You know, we have a global audience for this podcast and a lot of people look at the US American food system and they think, well, that that is a model that is and continues to be exported. And most of them look at the problems and issues, environmental and social harms connected to that. How do you think about that? Do you see it as a good or a bad model for export?

Jan
I mean, think the model tout court is as a whole is probably not a good idea to implement in other places. Sort of treating it as like a modular model of production, consumption and policy that you just plop in other places, I think is obviously quite noxious. Because I think in large part because of the incentives that exist in that system. So let’s just go back to the United States for a sec.

The United States, the reason we have so many problems in a food system that overall, otherwise, I think is quite good. Like I think the idea that we produce so much food, I think the fact that I can go into a supermarket and have a completely healthy vegan diet, whether I'm in Sioux City or Decatur or Brooklyn is on balance a wonderful thing. And I think we need to keep that. 

So just taking one more step back so I can answer your question completely. A lot of the ill health effects of the American diet have to do partially with food environments, but partially with food choice and food culture, which is why I said that ultimately this is about changing how individuals eat. 

The average food secure American, so let's say I'm talking about 86% of the population, could go into the average supermarket. They could go into the Walmart Supercenter and eat a far more healthful diet. That they don't is not a problem of the foods not being on the shelf. Of course, this is an argument that does not apply to food insecure Americans. So we're bracketing food insecure Americans. But we're talking about the vast majority of the population here. So it's something else driving the ill health effects. As for the negative environmental effects, again, our argument is that if we just leaned into very efficient crop production for human consumption,

That is ultimately a good model of producing a lot of crops in a way that is land efficient and that is labor efficient. The problem is that incentives exist for ill uses of land, such as growing food for feed or biofuels.

So I think that other countries looking to the American model, to the extent that they're not having the model foisted upon them by, for instance, American meat corporations, such as what's happening in Mexico with the rise of pork megafarms in Yucatan or what have you. I think if you look at the parts of that food system that work, which is basically really efficient crop production that makes a variety of food widely available and abundant to the average consumer, I think on balance, that's a very good thing.

I think if you're looking at the entire model, which is a model that under regulates, especially the most harmful parts of food production, and that really thinks about mass scale animal production and the use of crops to feed those animals or God forbid, ethanol production, then absolutely that is a poor idea because that is a terrible use of land. And it also incentivizes the use of more of the things that cause the problems we know it causes, right? So it requires the use of more petrochemical based fertilizers, which as we know, given the political situation now also presents a supply chain risk. It means the use of more pesticides. Of course, it means the use of more land. 

So the question then becomes like, what are the best practices in American agriculture and also in the American food system, right? The American food system itself as a whole has all kinds of best practice that also exists in some other places, right? Universal school lunches where they exist are the absolute top shelf best food security solution you have. So if you're looking to things that work in the American food system, you can look to places like New York City that serves 900,000 meals every single day. Studies show school lunches, despite the bad reputation they might have, are actually often the healthiest meals children will eat throughout the day.

If you're looking at more food insecurity solutions, you can look to things like SNAP, which is now being cut back, unfortunately, but basically, a cost of living adjusted cash handout in the form of an EBT card to increase the buying power of food insecure people. This is best practice. So I think if you're looking to the American food system, you could look to the things that work.

Embracing a production diet of more fuel and feed than food and embracing poor regulation and embracing, you know, junk food, if you will, is not the way to go.

Matthew
To wrap up, I know that Jan has been making the rounds with his book tour. I wanted to know how his argument travels to different audiences. In particular, if there were any topics that he gets more pushback on than others.

Jan

Well, honestly, I think the last question you asked, I mean, this is - we wrote a book about the United States. We gave a talk at UCSF, which was moderated by Brian Dowd-Uribe, who works on Global South Food Systems. And he's saying, look, the view from where I work, for instance, our views on GMOs who are quite, we're very pro GMO. Again, a category that means almost nothing. We're pro-genetic modification and gene editing where it leads to ends such as higher productivity for food crops for humans to eat and where it leads to things like climate change resistance, which is the next big frontier of where gene editing is going to go. 

 

But he says, look, programs to introduce gene editing as a sort of panacea for global South production haven't panned out. And there’s this question about applicability is a big one and I think food systems are also, they're highly contextual they're dependent on everything from demographics to pre-existing political economy, which is why I think we can't think of one single global food system model which is why our book is explicitly about the United States.

It's an important consideration when doing sort of comparative food politics between constituencies. And we're very honest. This is a book about the United States that starts in the now, recognizing we can't start from a blank slate. And that asks how, in the very particular context of the United States, we work to improve the food system. And I think that very often challenges to defenses of various aspects of the American or global north food system rest on using the Global South as a foil. And I think that that's the wrong way to go both ways. 

I think sort of the, if you will, if I can criticize Rob Paarlberg once in my life, I think the idea that if we just, look at what works and sort of say, you the green revolution was a great success off to the races globally is probably a little bit hubristic and often wrong contextually, but simultaneously, I think that one can't take a non sort of a view from outside the US and use it to critique food system solutions in the United States. I think that one can't take a non sort of a view from outside the US and use it to critique food system solutions in the United States, right? 

I'll give you an example. Well, if you support alternative protein, like, don't you just support corporate takeover of the food system? What does that mean about, you know, small-scale farmers in sub-Saharan Africa. Well, I'd say, mean, that's just, it's completely not an apposite critique or comparison. Impossible Burger isn't coming for those people's food system. The Impossible Burger is solution in the United States, which is a country where we only eat 220 pounds of meat each year. And we have terrible environmental externalities from our overconsumption of meat. In fact, anything, if anyone's going to challenge smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa, it's large meat companies that want to introduce factory farming and crops for feed to those contexts.

But I think we just need to keep things a little bit a little bit in context, but also not criticize the American food system from context just can't exist there. You can't say well, we just need more smallholder farmers in the United States. I mean that runs into myriad problems from land, from the literal costs of farmland as a barrier to entry to the nature of labor. If we can't have a United States made up of small farms, that ship is sailed. We need to think about solutions that exist in the here and now. 

Matthew

Yeah, I think it's a good place to end it. Jan Dutkiewicz, assistant professor at Pratt Institute and author of Feed the People, Why Industrial Food is Good and How to Make it Even Better. Thanks very much for speaking with us.

Jan 

Yeah, thank you for having me.

Matthew

Next week, we hear from the transform camp:

NikkI Yoxall

Industrial agriculture, whether it's crop production or animal production, prioritizes yield over everything else. And we can never always have yield and not have something else give. And I think that’s the challenge. People will talk about sustainable intensification, which in my view is an oxymoron. It's not possible to sustainably intensify, because it is ultimately extractive, and we're already operating beyond planetary boundaries. So ideas around, “lets just increase yield, something has to give.”

Matthew

It was four years ago I interviewed Jan Dutkiewicz for Meat: the four futures. He was featured in the Efficient and Plant-based episode. This conversation and their book feels like a logical progression. We’ll link to the series if you’d like to hear more, and all the other books and articles we talked about on our webpage: tabledebates.org/

A big thanks to you for listening. This Transform or Reform mini series is supported by the Laudes Foundation. Table is a collaboration of University of Oxford, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Wageneningen University in the Netherlands, University of the Andes in Colombia and National Autonomous University of Mexico. This episode was produced and edited by Matthew Kessler. Special thanks to Ruth Mattock for helping shape this series. Music by Blue dot Sessions. Talk to you soon.